Historic Elegance in Sunnyside – Restored Foursquare Near Crown Point Square
Step into timeless elegance with this beautifully restored Foursquare home located in the highly sought-after Sunnyside Historic District of Crown Point. Proudly blending historic character with thoughtful modern upgrades, this exceptional two-story residence offers 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a finished attic with dormers, and a partially finished basement — delivering space, sophistication, and enduring charm in one remarkable property.
From the moment you arrive, the home’s classic architectural presence captures attention. The traditional Foursquare design is known for its balanced proportions, spacious interiors, and refined detailing — and this residence exemplifies those qualities perfectly. Lovingly restored to reflect its original condition, the home showcases authentic craftsmanship while incorporating essential modern comforts.
Your tour begins with the stunning 31×9 enclosed sun porch — a true highlight of the home. Surrounded by windows, this inviting space is filled with natural light and serves as a welcoming introduction to the interior. Whether used as a morning sitting area, reading retreat, or seasonal entertaining space, the sun porch offers year-round enjoyment while maintaining the home’s historic aesthetic. Imagine sipping coffee as sunlight streams through the windows or relaxing in the evening with views of the quiet, tree-lined street.
Entering the formal living room, you are immediately greeted by rich hardwood floors, 9-foot ceilings, and exquisite original woodwork that speaks to the craftsmanship of a bygone era. The original fireplace, now equipped with a gas log, anchors the room with warmth and character. Its detailed surround and historical presence create a cozy yet refined focal point, perfect for gatherings or quiet evenings at home.
To the left of the living room, a charming parlour provides additional flexible space. This intimate room can function as a reading nook, music room, sitting area, or private office. The layout maintains the traditional flow of early 20th-century design while offering versatility for modern living.
The formal dining room is nothing short of impressive. Featuring elegant French doors and a beautifully preserved oak built-in buffet, this space radiates classic sophistication. The built-in cabinetry provides both style and practical storage, making it ideal for hosting dinner parties or holiday gatherings. The room’s generous proportions allow for a large dining table while maintaining comfortable movement throughout the space.
From the dining room, you transition seamlessly into the custom eat-in kitchen. Designed to complement the home’s historic character, the kitchen features built-in cabinets and durable Corian countertops that blend classic design with everyday functionality. Ample cabinetry ensures storage for all culinary needs, while the thoughtful layout makes meal preparation both efficient and enjoyable. The eat-in area offers a more casual dining option, perfect for everyday meals or informal gatherings.
Throughout the home, hardwood floors and stunning woodwork remain consistent, reinforcing the property’s authentic historic appeal. The craftsmanship is evident in every detail — from trim work and moldings to built-ins and architectural accents. The 9-foot ceilings enhance the sense of openness, allowing each room to feel spacious and airy.
The second floor hosts four well-appointed bedrooms, each offering comfort, natural light, and timeless charm. Whether used for family members, guests, or additional office space, these rooms provide flexibility and privacy. The primary suite and additional bedrooms maintain the home’s cohesive aesthetic, blending historic elements with livable comfort.
One of the most delightful surprises is the finished attic, complete with dormers that add architectural interest and natural light. This versatile space can serve as a bonus room, creative studio, playroom, or private retreat. The dormer windows create charming alcoves while expanding usable square footage, making this upper level both functional and inviting.
The partially finished basement significantly expands the home’s livable area. Here you’ll find a spacious laundry room, office area, family room, and a ¾ bathroom — offering convenience and practicality for daily life. The basement also includes a 16×12 shop space, ideal for hobbyists, DIY enthusiasts, or additional storage needs. Beneath the enclosed porch, a 31×9 storage area adds further utility, ensuring ample space for seasonal items and equipment.
Modern conveniences complement the home’s historic character. Recent upgrades provide peace of mind and energy efficiency, including a new high-efficiency boiler with two zones installed in 2022. This system allows for customized temperature control and improved heating performance. A new roof was also installed in 2022, enhancing structural integrity and long-term durability. In 2024, both the air conditioning system and water heater were replaced, ensuring reliable comfort and efficiency for years to come.
The exterior of the property is equally captivating. A detached two-car garage provides secure parking and additional storage. Surrounding the home are Period Gardens and Heritage rose gardens that enhance the property’s charm and curb appeal. These thoughtfully maintained gardens reflect the home’s historic roots while offering vibrant color and seasonal beauty. Mature landscaping frames the property, creating a picturesque setting in every direction.
Location is another exceptional advantage. Situated just three blocks from the historic Crown Point Square, this home offers the rare opportunity to enjoy walkable access to local shops, restaurants, community events, and charming architecture. The Square serves as the heart of Crown Point, hosting festivals, farmers markets, and seasonal celebrations throughout the year. Living here means embracing both history and community in one of the area’s most treasured neighborhoods.
The home’s proud inclusion in the 2000 Tri Kappa Tour of Homes further highlights its architectural and historical significance. This recognition underscores the property’s distinctive character and its importance within the community.
This Sunnyside Historic District residence is more than just a home — it is a piece of living history. From its enclosed sun porch and original fireplace to its oak built-ins, hardwood floors, and finished attic, every element reflects timeless design and thoughtful restoration. At the same time, recent upgrades ensure that modern comfort and efficiency are never compromised.
For buyers seeking historic charm, architectural integrity, generous living space, and an unbeatable location near Crown Point Square, this elegant Foursquare home presents a rare and compelling opportunity. Whether you are drawn to its classic woodwork, its spacious layout, or its beautifully maintained gardens, this property invites you to become part of its continuing story.
Experience the warmth, character, and enduring beauty of this restored historic treasure — where past and present blend seamlessly in one extraordinary home.
Listed on Zillow